Tessa Halstead

Knowing when to close

Closing the business was the hardest decision we made as owners, and one we’d make the same way again.

The situation

  • Profitable on paper, but never enough to pay ownership.
  • Costs were climbing: higher rent with a 2022 lease renewal, and rising labor and cocoa costs.
  • Sales plateaued in 2018–19. Growth meant more locations or more marketing, adding to those costs.
  • With our SBA loan due to be repaid in 2021, we were already weighing a choice: keep funding the business without an owner salary, or borrow again to grow.
  • COVID forced the decision. It put holiday retail, corporate gifting, additional locations and our credit line at risk.

What I did

  • Tested cash on hand against the holiday forecast, assuming a protracted COVID-19 disruption. Without new borrowing, cash would run out by early fall, months before the holidays could refill it.
  • Rallied our customer list and had our best Easter ever. But a strong spring didn't change the math: heading into Mother's Day we were at peak cash, and summer would draw it down.
  • With our loan three-quarters repaid, closing could settle everything from cash and equipment sales.
  • Scrutinized the numbers with my husband and co-owner, and together we made the call to close in May.
  • Held a final sale, negotiated our lease exit and settled every obligation.

What I learned

  • Act on the forecast. Because our seasonality was predictable and we understood our cash flows, closing at peak cash let us avoid putting more capital at risk on an uncertain holiday, skip the summer drain, and cover our team, our bank note and our lease exit from cash on hand.
  • Stopping is an active decision, for a product, a channel or a whole business. We'd defined success as a business that could pay its owners. When that wasn't in reach, we stopped on our terms instead of hoping.
  • How you say goodbye matters. From repaying our loan to delivering our last box of chocolates, we made sure everyone who invested in our success heard from us directly and was treated well. Closing on good terms allowed a painful chapter to become one I am proud of.
Exhibit

Holidays built our cash. Summer always drew it down.

Estimated month-end cash after our credit line, in thousands of dollars. Large dots are actual balance sheets; the dotted line shows summer 2020 if it had followed 2019.

How the exhibit was built →

This is a directional estimate, anchored to the balance sheets we gave our bank for December 2018, June 2019 and December 2019. Monthly sales come from our point-of-sale reports. Revenue outside the register, mostly December corporate gifting plus steady wholesale, is spread 70% across November to February and 30% across the other months. Costs are a fixed monthly base plus 30% of sales, with credit-card and tax payables settled the following month. Spring 2020 sales are my estimates: about $35k for Easter in April and about $28k in May with Mother's Day and our final sale. The SBA covered loan payments from April 2020.

Figures come from Chocolaterie Tessa's sales reports and the financial statements provided to our bank, 2018–2020, and are rounded. My husband and I owned the business together and made the big calls as a team. I owned forecasting, cash planning and day-to-day operations; he kept the books and handled annual reporting.